What drives Moen faucet replacement and how large is the repair/replace market?

Faucet replacement drivers: faucets are replaced for multiple reasons: malfunction (leaking, worn internal cartridges, stripped handles — faucets have a useful life of 10-25 years depending on quality and use); aesthetics and renovation (updating a bathroom or kitchen's look during a remodel; faucet style changes every 10-15 years); water-saving mandates (building codes increasingly require low-flow fixtures when replacing faucets in renovations); smart home upgrades (touchless, voice-controlled, or app-connected faucets are consumer upgrade products). Market size: the U.S. has approximately 140 million housing units; most homes have 3-5 faucets (kitchen, bathrooms, laundry); with faucets needing replacement every 15-20 years, the annual replacement market is approximately 50-70 million faucets per year; at an average price of $100-300 per faucet, this represents a $5-15 billion annual market in the U.S. alone. Why Moen wins: Moen's market position benefits from: contractor and plumber loyalty (plumbers trust Moen's quality and availability of replacement parts; plumbers who recommend brands to homeowners are a critical influence channel); home improvement retailer shelf presence (Moen has excellent positioning at Home Depot and Lowe's, the primary faucet purchase locations); lifetime warranty (Moen's limited lifetime warranty signals quality confidence, reducing consumer risk aversion on a $150-400 purchase); brand heritage and advertising (Moen's 'Buy it for looks. Buy it for life.' marketing reinforces premium brand positioning). Renovation market resilience: renovation spending is more resilient than new construction spending through housing cycles; homeowners who can't afford to move (due to high mortgage rates locking them into existing low-rate mortgages) invest in renovating their current home instead; this 'lock-in effect' from the 2022+ rising rate environment actually increased renovation spending as homeowners improved existing homes rather than selling.

What is composite decking and what is the Fiberon brand's growth opportunity?

Composite decking vs. wood: traditional outdoor decks are built from pressure-treated lumber (pine or fir treated with preservatives to resist moisture and insects) or exotic hardwoods (ipe, teak); wood decking requires regular maintenance (staining, sealing, painting every 1-3 years) and eventually rots, warps, and splinters; composite decking is made from a combination of wood fiber and recycled plastic materials (often recycled HDPE from plastic bags) molded into deck boards; composite decking doesn't need staining or sealing, doesn't rot, and doesn't splinter; premium composite products from Fiberon (FBIN), Trex (publicly traded), TimberTech (AZEK), and others have captured significant market share from wood decking. Outdoor living trend: U.S. homeowners have significantly expanded investment in outdoor living spaces — decks, patios, outdoor kitchens, pergolas, fire pits, and outdoor furniture; the COVID-19 pandemic dramatically accelerated outdoor space investment as people spent more time at home; this trend has sustained post-COVID; professional outdoor living design has moved from a luxury to a mainstream home improvement category. Fiberon's position: Fiberon is a mid-to-premium composite decking brand that competes with Trex (the market leader), TimberTech, and Azek; Fiberon's products are available at home centers and through lumber distribution (including Builders FirstSource); FBIN acquired Fiberon to expand its outdoor portfolio alongside Larson storm doors. Market dynamics: composite decking has been penetrating wood decking's market share for 20+ years; composite now represents approximately 45-50% of the total decking market vs. 5% in the early 2000s; the remaining wood decking market (approximately 50-55%) represents continued conversion opportunity; this penetration story provides structural growth for composite deck manufacturers independent of housing starts.

How sensitive is Fortune Brands' revenue to new construction vs. renovation/remodel?

Revenue split by end market: Fortune Brands' 2022-2023 management discussion suggested approximately 30-35% of revenue has meaningful new construction exposure (primarily Therma-Tru entry doors, which are predominantly installed in new homes); 65-70% of revenue is repair, remodel, and replacement (Moen faucets, Master Lock products, most composite decking replacements). Therma-Tru doors and new construction: Therma-Tru fiberglass and steel entry doors are the leading brand in new residential construction for entry doors; when D.R. Horton, Lennar, or PulteGroup builds a new home, the entry door is frequently a Therma-Tru product; Therma-Tru's revenue therefore directly correlates with housing starts; a 30% decline in housing starts (as occurred in 2022-2023) reduces Therma-Tru volume by a similar percentage. Moen and the renovation market: Moen faucets are split between new construction (installed in new homes' kitchens and bathrooms) and renovation/replacement (installed in existing homes during bathroom or kitchen remodels or when the existing faucet fails); the renovation/replacement portion of Moen's volume is significantly larger than the new construction portion; faucets have a 15-20 year replacement cycle driven by wear and consumer preference changes; this creates a large installed base of aging faucets generating steady replacement demand. 'Lock-in effect' benefit: when mortgage rates rose sharply in 2022-2023, existing homeowners with 2.5-3.5% fixed-rate mortgages were reluctant to sell and buy a new home with a 7%+ mortgage; instead, many invested in renovating their existing homes; Moen faucet demand from bathroom/kitchen renovation benefited from this 'lock-in' behavior that kept homeowners investing in existing homes rather than buying new ones; this dynamic actually benefited Fortune Brands' renovation-exposed revenue during the period when new construction fell.

brimindinvest.com / compare / bldr-vs-fbhsLIVE

BLDR

Builders FirstSource, Inc. · Industrials - Building Products Distribution and Manufacturing

$80.59

+21.39% this month

VERSUS

⟷

COMPARE

FBIN

Fortune Brands Innovations, Inc. · Consumer Discretionary - Building Products Brands (Home Security, Water, Outdoor)

$42.40

+27.90% this month

Scoreboard verdict

Across AI score, momentum, valuation, upside, operating margin

BLDR

2

FBIN

2

MIXED SETUP

Comparison scoreboard

MIXED SETUP

AI Score

BLDR ✓50.9

FBIN 26.5

1Y Return

BLDR -25.37%

FBIN ✓-12.56%

Fwd P/E

BLDR 13.71

FBIN ✓11.59

Target Up.

BLDR ✓+20.84%

FBIN +11.39%

Op. Margin

BLDR 0.50%

FBIN N/A

Metrics last refreshed: 6/22/2026

Quick take

BLDR vs FBIN Stock Comparison: AI Score, Valuation, Performance and Upside

BLDR (Builders FirstSource) and FBIN (Fortune Brands Innovations) are both building products companies with distinct business models and housing cycle exposures — Builders FirstSource is highly cyclical and directly tied to new housing starts as the largest supplier of structural building materials and manufactured components to homebuilders, while Fortune Brands Innovations is more consumer-oriented with Moen (faucets), Master Lock (security), and Therma-Tru (doors) serving both new construction and renovation/repair replacement markets.

BLDR vs FBIN is large-scale building materials distributor and component manufacturer directly tied to new housing starts (Builders FirstSource's lumber distribution, prefabricated truss manufacturing, and homebuilder relationships — high housing cycle sensitivity and lumber price volatility) versus consumer building product brands with renovation/repair revenue stability (Fortune Brands' Moen faucet brand strength, Master Lock security market dominance, and composite decking outdoor living growth — Therma-Tru new construction exposure and premium brand competitive pressure from lower-cost alternatives).

Live analysis · updated 6/22/2026

BLDR and FBIN are closely matched — they split the tracked metrics evenly. FBIN leads on both 1-year return (-12.56%) and forward P/E (11.59x vs 13.71x for BLDR), a relatively favorable combination of momentum and valuation. Analyst consensus implies meaningfully more upside for BLDR (+20.84%) than for FBIN (+11.39%).

Normalized 1Y performance

BLDR

FBIN

Recent returns

BLDR

FBIN

Analyst price targets & sentiment

BLDR

Price target range

analyst mean$97.38
current price$80.59

+20.8% upside to analyst mean

FBIN · 13 analysts

STRONG BUYHOLDSTRONG SELL

Hold (2.7/5.0)

Price target range

analyst low$37.00
analyst high$63.00
analyst mean$47.23
current price$42.40

+11.4% upside to analyst mean

Who should consider this stock?

BLDR may suit investors who:

→Want maximum building materials exposure to a housing start recovery thesis through the largest U.S. distributor and manufactured component supplier to professional homebuilders with scale purchasing and logistics advantages
→Value Builders FirstSource's shift toward manufactured components (trusses, wall panels) and digital services as structural mix-shift improving margins beyond pure commodity lumber distribution
→Accept high housing cycle sensitivity and lumber price volatility in exchange for BLDR's market leadership position that captures significant upside when housing starts normalize

FBIN may suit investors who:

→Want building products exposure with more defensive revenue characteristics through Moen and Master Lock brand strength serving the larger repair/replace and renovation market with less direct new construction dependency
→Value Fortune Brands' consumer brand portfolio where Moen's faucet brand recognition and Master Lock's padlock market dominance create pricing power and consumer loyalty that commodity building material distributors cannot replicate
→Believe the composite decking/outdoor living trend (Fiberon) provides a secular growth driver within building products that is not dependent on new housing construction cycles

Performance & AI score

Metric	BLDR	FBIN
AI score	50.9	26.5
AI rank	#407	#2594
Latest close	$80.59	$42.40
1M return	+21.39%	+27.90%
6M return	-22.14%	-17.14%
1Y return	-25.37%	-12.56%

$10,000 invested — hypothetical growth (dividends reinvested)

How much would $10,000 be worth today if invested at the start of each period, with all dividends reinvested?

Period	BLDR	FBIN
1Y ago	$7.54K (-24.6%) started 2025-06-18	$8.93K (-10.7%) started 2025-06-18
5Y ago	$18.37K (+83.7%) started 2021-06-21	$6.07K (-39.3%) started 2021-06-18
10Y ago	$70.63K (+606.3%) started 2016-06-20	$11.64K (+16.4%) started 2016-06-20

Hypothetical — past performance does not guarantee future results.

Valuation & upside potential

Metric	BLDR	FBIN
Market cap	$8.67B	$5.06B
Trailing P/E	30.76	18.84
Forward P/E	13.71	11.59
Price/Sales	N/A	1.14
EV/Revenue	0.94	1.76
Analyst target	$97.38	$47.23
Target upside	+20.84%	+11.39%

Growth, profitability & risk

Metric	BLDR	FBIN
Revenue growth	-10.10%	-2.10%
Earnings growth	-82.90%	-52.40%
EPS growth	-82.90%	-52.40%
FCF margin	+4.32%	+7.29%
Operating margin	0.50%	N/A
Profit margin	1.97%	6.12%
ROIC proxy	6.96%	11.65%
Return on equity	6.96%	11.65%
Dividend yield	N/A	2.45%
Beta	1.45	1.45
Debt/equity	132.16	125.71
Current ratio	1.76	2.13
Quick ratio	1.01	0.85

Drawdown & downside risk

Lower drawdown and smaller single-period drops generally indicate a smoother ride, though they do not guarantee lower future risk.

1Y risk snapshot

BLDR max drawdown55.51%

FBIN max drawdown47.93%

BLDR max wkly drop17.95%

FBIN max wkly drop17.03%

5Y risk snapshot

BLDR max drawdown68.55%

FBIN max drawdown61.90%

BLDR max wkly drop22.54%

FBIN max wkly drop20.31%

10Y risk snapshot

BLDR max drawdown68.55%

FBIN max drawdown62.42%

BLDR max wkly drop45.38%

FBIN max wkly drop33.56%

Performance metrics by period

Period	Metric	BLDR	FBIN
1Y	Growth	-24.58%	-12.56%
	CAGR	-24.61%	-12.57%
	Sharpe ratio	-0.43	-0.19
	Max drawdown	55.51%	47.93%
	Max daily drop	6.43%	17.62%
	Max wkly drop	17.95%	17.03%
5Y	Growth	+83.66%	-43.95%
	CAGR	+12.95%	-10.93%
	Sharpe ratio	0.40	-0.25
	Max drawdown	68.55%	61.90%
	Max daily drop	19.05%	17.62%
	Max wkly drop	22.54%	20.31%
10Y	Growth	+606.31%	-0.40%
	CAGR	+21.60%	-0.04%
	Sharpe ratio	0.56	0.05
	Max drawdown	68.55%	62.42%
	Max daily drop	23.27%	17.62%
	Max wkly drop	45.38%	33.56%

Business comparison

Category	BLDR	FBIN
Company	Builders FirstSource, Inc.	Fortune Brands Innovations, Inc.
Sector	Industrials	Consumer Discretionary - Building Products Brands (Home Security, Water, Outdoor)
Industry	N/A	N/A
Core business	Builders FirstSource is the largest U.S. supplier of building materials, manufactured components, and construction services to professional homebuilders, sub-contractors, and building professionals. BLDR's business includes: distribution of commodity building products (dimensional lumber, engineered wood, OSB, roofing, windows, doors, millwork, insulation); manufacturing of prefabricated components (roof and floor trusses, structural wall panels, stair systems — products manufactured off-site and installed on the construction site); and value-added services (design/estimation software, installed sales). BLDR serves approximately 40,000+ customer locations including major homebuilders (D.R. Horton, NVR, Lennar), smaller production builders, and custom homebuilders. BLDR generated approximately $16-17 billion in annual revenue at its post-COVID peak before moderation.	Fortune Brands Innovations (spun off from Fortune Brands Home & Security as a standalone company) is a consumer and professional brand company in home and security products across three segments: Security (Master Lock padlocks and security products, Therma-Tru doors); Water (Moen faucets, showers, and plumbing fixtures; House of Rohl luxury bath and kitchen fixtures); and Outdoors (Larson storm doors, FIBERON composite decking, and Fiberon outdoor living products). FBIN's brands serve both new construction (Therma-Tru doors in new homes) and renovation/repair and remodeling (Moen faucets replacing old fixtures). FBIN generates approximately $5-6 billion in annual net sales.
Investor focus	Investors track Builders FirstSource's revenue (with commodity lumber prices and housing starts as primary drivers), gross margin trajectory as the mix shifts from commodity distribution to higher-margin manufactured components and value-added services, and free cash flow generation.	Investors track Fortune Brands' organic sales growth across segments (particularly Moen's repair/replace demand and Therma-Tru's new construction exposure), operating margin improvement, and the revenue split between new construction and renovation/remodel that determines Housing cycle sensitivity.

BLDR strengths

→Largest scale in residential building distribution provides purchasing and logistics advantages — BLDR's scale allows it to purchase commodity lumber and building products at favorable prices and maintain extensive regional distribution infrastructure that smaller competitors cannot replicate
→Manufactured components business provides higher-margin, differentiated revenue — roof trusses, floor trusses, and wall panels are engineered and manufactured to each job's specific specifications; these products carry higher margins than commodity distribution and reduce on-site labor requirements for builders
→Digital and value-added services (design software, estimation tools) deepen customer relationships — BLDR's digital tools help homebuilders design houses and estimate materials, making BLDR a planning partner rather than just a material supplier; this integration increases customer dependency and switching costs

FBIN strengths

→Brand strength in Moen and Master Lock provides pricing power and consumer preference — Moen is one of the most recognized faucet brands in the U.S.; Master Lock is the dominant padlock brand; these brand positions command premium pricing vs. unbranded alternatives and reduce price sensitivity
→Renovation and repair market reduces new construction housing cycle sensitivity — Moen faucets are frequently replaced in remodeling projects regardless of new home construction activity; Master Lock sales are not dependent on housing starts; this repair/replace revenue provides stability when new construction slows
→Composite decking (Fiberon) benefits from long-term outdoor living trend — composite decking (made from recycled materials) is replacing pressure-treated wood decking in new construction and replacement markets; it requires less maintenance than wood; the outdoor living trend (expanded outdoor spaces) drives demand for composite decking regardless of new construction activity

Risks to watch — BLDR

→Housing cycle sensitivity creates significant revenue volatility — new housing starts (single-family and multifamily) directly drive BLDR's material volumes; rate increases (2022-2023) significantly reduced housing affordability and housing starts, compressing BLDR's revenue; housing starts recovery is essential for revenue normalization
→Commodity lumber prices create significant revenue and margin volatility — lumber prices are notoriously volatile ($300/thousand board feet to $1,700/MBF and back within 18 months in 2020-2021); BLDR's commodity distribution revenue rises and falls dramatically with lumber prices, creating volatile reported results
→Labor shortages in homebuilding constrain construction volumes — a shortage of construction workers slows homebuilding pace even when demand exists; BLDR's volume is constrained by how quickly builders can complete homes

Risks to watch — FBIN

→New construction exposure (Therma-Tru doors) creates housing cycle sensitivity — Therma-Tru fiberglass entry doors are primarily installed in new homes; housing start declines reduce Therma-Tru volumes; approximately 30% of FBIN revenue has meaningful new construction exposure
→Competition from lower-priced alternatives in faucets and security products — Chinese-manufactured plumbing fixtures and padlocks compete at lower price points; value-conscious consumers may trade down to lower-priced alternatives, particularly during economic stress
→Moen and other brands require continuous innovation to maintain premium positioning — without ongoing innovation (water-saving technology, touchless faucets, smart home integration), brand positioning can erode; R&D investment is required to maintain the product's technological superiority vs. alternatives

Frequently asked questions

Prefabricated components definition: prefabricated (or 'prefab') structural building components are manufactured at a facility and delivered to the construction site ready for installation — rather than cutting, assembling, and nailing components on-site; the primary prefab components in residential construction include: roof trusses (the triangular structural framework supporting the roof, engineered and manufactured in a truss plant with precise angles, spans, and load capacities calculated by engineers), floor trusses (horizontal structural members supporting floors in multi-story construction), structural wall panels (exterior or interior wall sections pre-framed with studs, blocking, and sometimes sheathing applied off-site), stair systems (complete stair assemblies with treads, risers, and stringers pre-built for installation), and window and door packages (windows and doors pre-ordered, often pre-hung in frames, delivered to the job site for installation). Why prefab is valuable: labor savings — on-site framing labor is expensive and in short supply; prefab components reduce the skilled labor required on-site; speed — a roof truss crane set takes a skilled crew one day to complete the roof structure that might otherwise take 3-5 days of stick-framing; quality control — factory-built components are engineered and manufactured under quality control, reducing field construction errors; waste reduction — components are cut to exact specifications in the factory with minimal waste vs. job-site material cutting. Margin advantage: BLDR's manufactured components business generates gross margins significantly above commodity distribution; a builder who pays BLDR to engineer, manufacture, and crane-set the roof trusses is buying a high-value service, not just lumber; as BLDR grows its manufactured components percentage, gross margin mix improves.

AI Prediction SignalNext 5 trading days

Members only

BLDR

+2.8%BUY

FBIN

+1.1%HOLD

Start Free Trial Log in

ML model trained on historical prices · 14-day free trial · No credit card required

Free public comparison

Want deeper AI forecasts?

This comparison page is public and free forever. Subscribers can unlock saved watchlists, full AI rankings, detailed forecasts, and interactive analysis tools.

Start Free Trial Read Investing Guides